While working as a nurse, Cullen killed at least 40 patients during his 16-year career. Investigators in the field near the spot where Jane Durrua's body was found in 1968 in East Keansburg. Among many of the cases listed on various law enforcement websites and other public databases or lists are some of the many unsolved murders in northern New Jersey, including the 1992 murder of Renae McLoed, the 2013 murder of Chrismely Hidalgo, the 2014 murder of Jermaine Gamble, and the 1990 murder of Maria Acevedo, among many others. No one else was ever arrested for the double murder. Squire, who is also known as Sundiata Acoli, was convicted in Foerster's murder and remains in prison. Uncovered: Unsolved New Jersey Murders Compare this to the Trenton, New Jersey, murders rate,which was 19.1 per 100,000 people in 2018, and the violent crime rate in Trenton, New Jersey,which was 1161.75 per 100,000 people that same year. He gave his patients lethal overdoses, later claiming he was trying to ease their suffering. Burr died on Staten Island in 1836 at 80. Here are ten of the more gruesome murders in New York, pre-1905. Stephanie "Star" Rosado, 26, of S. Merrimac Road in Camden, was last seen around April 12, 2009, authorities said. Workers remove the urn continaing the ashes of Larry Dean, believed to be one of Charles Cullen's murder victims, from his grave in Phillipsburg in 2004. Throughout the years, there have been several famous homicides in New Jersey - each story more chilling than the next. The most notorious, unsolved murder cases in each of N.J.'s 21 counties Police then lobbed tear gas into the house and Unruh surrendered, telling them, "I'd have killed a thousand if I'd had bullets enough." Experts have estimated that Charles Cullen killed over 300 patients throughout his 16-year nursing career, starting in 1988. WOW. On Nov. 15, 1988, Joseph M. Harris, angered over a soured investment with Roy Edwards, donned a black ninja costume, black mask and gloves, and forced his way into Edwards' Montville home, where he sexually assaulted the man's wife and two young daughters. She was believed to be between the ages of 14 and 18 at the time of her death. Bergen County: Community activist Joan Davis. Some of the most well-known or infamous New Jersey murders that are most often found on the list of New Jersey murders include the 1976 murder of Cynthia Leeds, the 2007 murder of Lockey Mitten, the 2010 murder of Diane Mary Zaleski, the 1977 murder of Sigrid Stevenson, and the 2001 murder of Michelle Howard, among many others. Wendy Sue Wolin's stepbrother and sister, Jules Fleischner and Jodi Wolin, pose near a small garden marking the spot where Wendy, then seven, was stabbed to death near her apartment in 1966. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. She never left and according to some, she is still there today. On May 2, 1973, a car carrying Joanne Chesimard of the Black Liberation Army and two others waspulled over on the New Jersey Turnpike in East Brunswick by State Trooper James H. Harper, who noticed a broken taillight and called fellow trooper Werner Foerster for back-up. Kuklinski was captured after investigators linked him to several unsolved homicides, and an undercover federal agent posing as another hit man got close to him and sold Kuklinski what he claimed was pure cyanide. Noga died from a blow to the head. Despite testimony from psychiatrists that Kallinger suffered from paranoid schizophrenia, he was also convicted of those murders. Bruno Richard Hauptmann, the German immigrant convicted in the Lindbergh baby kidnapping. The following include a few of the most notorious New Jersey serial killers who are regularly featured on various lists:Clarence Hill, also known as The Duck Island Killer, who murdered 3 couples (6 total) from 1938-1940; Richard Francis Cottingham, also known as The Torso Killer, who murdered at least 6 women from 1977-1980; and Charles Edmund Cullen, a nurse, who is believed to have killed between 29 and 45 patients from 1984-2003 in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. There, he was reached by phone by an editor of the Camden Evening Courier, who asked him how many people he had killed. Some of the most common items of evidence that are included in homicide trials include DNA evidence, such as blood, saliva, and skin cells, and digital evidence such as cell phone pings. died after a seizure at the State Correctional Institute at Cresson, Pa. Princess Doe composite (New Jersey State Police). It's speculated the number could be much higher than that, into the hundreds. Built In 1957, The Caribbean Motel Is A Historic Inn In New Jersey That Was Once The Heart Of Doo-Wop Culture, Here Are The 5 Most-Recommended BBQ Restaurants In New Jersey, According To Our Readers, Enjoy A Farm-To-Glass Brewing Experience At This Unique Brewery In New Jersey, Few People Know About This New Jersey Quarry Filled With Dinosaur Tracks, Not Many People Know About The Deadliest Serial Killer To Stalk New Jersey, These 8 Famous Homicides In New Jersey Will Never Be Forgotten, These 7 Evil People From New Jersey Left A Dark Stain On History, 13 Reasons That New Jersey Is The Most Terrifying, Spookiest State, Choochart Choochaikupt / EyeEm via Getty Images. In 2001, he was tried but ultimately acquitted in the shooting death of Rahway police officer Charles Bernoskie in 1958. James Kauffman, a 69-year-old endocrinologist, hasn't been named as a suspect, but he was arrested on June 13 following a45-minute armed standoffat his medical office in Egg Harbor. On Sept. 6, 1949, World War II veteran Howard Unruh killed 13 people. (Star-Ledger file photo). New Jersey is a beautiful state and home to wonderful people anyone who lives here knows that. Information may also be emailed toccpotips@ccprosecutor.org. In 1983, Biegenwald became the suspect in the death of Anna Olesiewicz, 18, of Camden, whodisappeared from the Asbury Park boardwalk and whose body was found, shot in the head, behind a Burger King in Ocean Township. New York City, one of the most famous cities in the world, has a reputationdeserved or notfor violence. His son, Charles Jr., was abducted from the family's East Amwell home on the evening of March 1st, 1932. Sigrid Stevenson, 25, was found beaten to death and naked on the main stage of Kendall Hall's theater at then-Trenton State College on Sept. 4, 1977, just four days before classes started. ", A former congregant confessed in 2000 that the rabbipaid him and another man beat Carol Neulander to death. How many are getting away with murder in N.J.? A $10,000 reward still stands for information on Mitten's death. The prosecutor's office released a sketch of a suspect shortly after the killing. He was 68. (Newark Evening News). The victim is believed to have been killed on or about Jan. 1, 2006. Possibly one of the most famous unsolved mysteries in New Jersey history, you can see famed aviator Charles Lindbergh on the witness stand above. Michael Kallinger pleaded guilty to two counts of armed robbery, was eventually released from juvenile custody, moved out of state and changed his name. Charles Cullen is New Jersey's most prolific serial killer. Creepy Unsolved Mysteries In NJ To Give You The Creeps - OnlyInYourState Mafia Hit List - Top New Jersey Mob Murders 9 years ago Scott Burnstein You are unauthorized to view this page. His mother simply believed he had a play date but when he did not return by that evening the family grew concerned. Joanne Chesimard, arrested in the murder of Trooper Werner Foerster, at the Middlesex County Courthouse in 1976. She and the other husband started an affair, and soon after the man's wifedied after drinking arsenic-tainted milk. A serial killer convicted for the murder of three women in New Jersey, and a near-fatal attack on a fourth, was charged Thursday in the murder of a 15-year-old girl who went missing from her . The legends | N.J.'s most notorious murders - nj.com (AP file photo). new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help Edwards' wife smashed a window and screamed for help; a neighbor called police. $0.00. The body of 25 year old Sigrid Stevenson was found on the main stage of the music hall (shown above), beaten and bloody. (Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office). Investigators wanted to test the body for traces of digoxin, Cullen's poison of choice. But in 2005, DNA evidence linked him to the 1968 murder of 13-year-old Jane Durrua. FindNJ.com/Entertainment on Facebook. It looks like a pretty good score." Matthew Carroll, then 26 and a Marine Corps captain, told police he took the couple's children, ages 2 and 5, to Long Island for a visit on May 1, 2000, and, when he returned the next day, he reported his wife missing. We believe the more resources we can provide to digital volunteers and citizen solvers mean more citizen detective communities. Additionally, you can find a few unsolved murders Trenton, New Jersey, on these websites and within several cold case lists, including the 2013 murder of Cornelius Boakai and the 2012 murder of Joshua Moore. Three people were shot and killed at Lafayette Bar & Grill on East 18th Street in Paterson on June 17, 1966 James Oliver, Fred Nauyoks and Hazel Tanis. 1. A neighborhood youngster saw her get into a car with two men. to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really Some of these names may include some of the most notorious New Jersey criminals, serial killers, or even victims. Clinton Avenue Five - Wikipedia Philadelphia cobbler Joseph Kallinger, who claimed he was working on orders from God, went on a home invasion and sexual assault spree withhis teenaged son Michael starting in late 1974. target no need to return item. He killed multiple people for profit -- officially he is credited with five murderers, although he's since claimed to be responsible for the killings of Jimmy Hoffa and other mob bosses. (Ervin Hess). There have been no suspects or leads in her murder and it remains a cold case. You'll receive your first newsletter soon! Flora Rheta Schreiber, the author of "Sybil," became interested in the case and Kallinger admitted to her that he had also killed his son Joey, then 14, and a 10-year-old neighbor before the robbery spree began. Anyone with informationcan contact the Essex County Prosecutor's Office Homicide/Major Crimes Task Force tips line at 1-877-TIPS-4EC or 1-877-847-7432. Two years later, Coppolino and his wife Carmela moved to Florida, where Carmela died suddenly, justafterCoppolino increased his wife's insurance policy. Garrulous gangster taken out of commission, 1951. (Essex County Prosecutor's Office). Trenton, New Jersey, murderstend to be significantly lesscommon than murdersin many other New Jersey cities due to its relatively small size, compared to Newark and Jersey City. During recent times, many residents of New Jersey have hogged the limelight for their achievements. NAPOLETANO Jr. During a massive search for the missing child, law enforcement officers ascertained that there were three sex offenders Joseph Cifelli, Jesse Timmendequas, then 36, and Brian Jenin living across the street from the Kanka family. tipton, iowa obituaries. (Star-Ledger file photo). (Amanda Brown | Star-Ledger), Once imprisoned, Kuklinski made hyperbolic claims about his career, even boasting at one point that he killed Jimmy Hoffa. (Patti Sapone | Star-Ledger file photo). Sadly, weve also made headlines for homicides. According to the latest census, Trenton, New Jerseys state capital, has a population of only around82,000 people, substantially fewer than the states major cities such as Jersey City and Newark. Investigators speculated that fellow mob leaders wanted Morettisilenced after the talkative gangster, said to be suffering brain damage fromsyphilis, testified (but did not incriminate anyone) before local and federal committees on organized crime. On the afternoon of January 13, 1996, nine-year-old Amber Hagerman and her five-year-old brother Ricky were playing, as they often did, in an abandoned grocery store parking lot in . KOMIN. He shot and killed a local newspaper editor who opposed him, but was found not guilty by reason of insanity. In 1970, businessman Wesley Diggs and his wife, Jean, moved their family from Harlem to the small town of Teaneck, New Jersey. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. Linden nativeRobert Zarinskywas the firstperson ever convicted in New Jersey without evidence of a corpse. Occasionally, these discussions focus onTrenton murders pictures, Trenton murders crime scene photos, and Trenton, New Jersey, murders autopsy photos, which are typically not publicly disclosed even when an investigation comes to an end. Cherry Hill rabbi Fred Neulander was convicted of hiring a former congregant to kill his wife Carol in 1994. In 1989, his story was told on "America's Most Wanted" and he was finally captured. Only two were actually deemed insane. Follow Inside Jersey on Twitter. For the task, Kallinger recruited his 12-year-old son Michael, and in 1974, the two embarked on a home invasion spree in New Jersey, Maryland and Pennsylvania, robbing homes and sexually assaulting the women. 5. This past May, the Atlantic County Prosecutor's Office filed a motion requesting the DNA of Kauffman's husband, James Kauffman, which he has opposed. He's been featured in multiple movies and documentaries. Kallinger left behind a bloodstained shirt with a laundry label that led to police to him. In September 2011, Floria Turner-McDowell (not a relative of victim Michael McDowell), mother of victim Alvin Turner, had her son declared dead and filed a wrongful death suit against Evans and Hampton two months later. COMING WEDNESDAY: Part II of N.J's most notorious murders the lovers. He was diagnosed with schizophrenia and spent the remainder of his life at Trenton Psychiatric Hospital, where he died in 2009 at the age of 88. The crime remained unsolved, but the ninja resurfaced on Oct. 9, 1991 this time in Wayne. An enraged Landis, who reportedly did have a stormy relationship with his wife, chased Carruth through the newspaper offices and shot him in the back of the head. She was a friend of John and Joyce. Anyone with information on the stabbing cancall the Monmouth County Prosecutors Office tips line at 1-800-533-7443. "I don't know. He was also convicted in the four other murders. Some of these names may include some of the most notorious New Jersey criminals, serial killers, or even victims. Part IV of N.J.'s most notorious murders the mobsters. Landis' lawyer claimed he suffered from temporary insanity, which Attorney General Jacob Vanatta characterized as the sort that "never occurs with anyone unless he is very rich or holds some high social position," according to "Notorious New Jersey: 100 True Tales of Murders and Mobsters, Scandals and Scoundrels.". Rev. He is eligible for parole in 2403. His final victims were the pharmacist and the man's wife and mother, after which Unruh returned home. And yet Creighton might have escaped notice had a packet of newspaper clippings about the Newark poisonings not found its way to investigators on Long Island. Coppolino served 12 years and was paroled in 1979, published a memoir called "The Crime That Never Was," about the case, and then completely dropped off the radar. famous murders in new jersey - mail.latcosmic.com Hamiltondied the next day in New York, and authorities in both New York and New Jerseyindicted Burr for murder, although he was not convicted. Serial killer who murdered entire family hid in plain sight for years Mary Frances Creighton with her husband John, and their two children Ruth and John Jr. Creighton. Lastly, east New Jersey unsolved murders are also included within the various databases or lists, including the 1996 murder of Smita Amin Patel, the 1996 murder of Hae Sook Lee, the 1997 murder of Sara Lepkofker, the 2006 murder of Patricia DaSilva, and the 2001 murder of Michelle Howard, among many others. In 1997, Timmendequas was convicted in the murder and sentenced to death, though that wascommuted to life in prisonwhen New Jersey abolished the death penalty in 2007. Another valuable resource is Project: Cold Case who, in partnership with the Murder Accountability Project, has created a webpage that shows the number of unsolved homicides in each state along with their respective homicide clearance rate. (Newark Public Library | Star-Ledger file photo). The Watcher John Graff family murder is based on true story | EW.com Condon met twice in a Bronx cemetery with the kidnapper, who called himself John and had a pronounced accent, and then. (Noah K. Murray | Star-Ledger file photo), Carol Neulander was beaten to death in herCherry Hill home on Nov. 1, 1994, but it wasn't untilfour years later that police had enough evidence to arrest her husband Fred Neulander, a rabbi with a wandering eye, for murder. A friend of Biegenwald told police that Biegenwald killed three other teens and a drug dealer since 1981 and told them where to find the bodies. A rabbi with a roving eye, a housewife whose secret ingredient was arsenic, a failing financial planner who requested cremations for the family that he killed(more economical),a real estate mogul in a nasty feud with a newsman: the Garden State has been home to some of thenation's most singularmurderers, and some of the most horrifying acts of revenge, greed, jealousy, insanity, perversion and pure evil. He got his nickname after he dismembered his two victims and set the torsos on fire. (Star-Ledger file photo). Odds are youll see a couple of names on the list of all murders in New Jersey or list of murders in Jersey that at least seem familiar. A bust of John List was commissioned by 'America's Most Wanted' in 1989 for a segment on the 1971 murders. Butcavage, who is currently in prison in Pennsylvania, has never been charged in connection with Himebaugh's disappearance. Regardless, New Jerseys various law enforcement organizationswill never give up their investigations into these crimes byutilizing all of the resources at their disposal in order tosolve all of New Jerseys true crimes. Here are the 21 most notorious murders, crime sprees and serial killers in New Jersey history. Anyone with information about McBride's death can contact the Sussex County Prosecutor's Office at 973-383-1570. Authorities say Johnson and a male passenger were traveling west on Levitt Parkway toward Route 130 in Willingboro when the Buick struck a Dodge Lancer that was stopped at the traffic light. Odds are youll see a couple of names on the list of all murders in New Jersey or list of murders in Jersey that at least seem familiar. As you may expect, the Trenton murders discussion will continueon social media sites such asReddit, Facebook, andWebsleuths, where individuals often gather to share their opinions, theories, and other informationabout these cases. After she hung up the phone, Thor told her parents she'd be right back and ran from the house. Tell us in the comments. Charles Cullen, the nurse who administered fatal doses of drugs to at least 29 of his patients in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Marshall was convicted of murder in 1986 and sentenced to death by lethal injection, but it was overturned in 2004 because of ineffective legal counsel during the death penalty phase. Joan Davis, 74, a political watchdog and outspoken gadfly, was found bludgeonedto death inside her Tudor-style home along Teaneck's Alpine Drive in August 2010. "He was a quiet one, that guy. The lunatics | N.J.'s most notorious murders - nj.com Did He Kill Neighbor to Become 'TikTok Famous - The New York Times Eric Ernest Joseph Harris's lawyers claimed that a ninja spirit guided him when the former postal worker killed four people in 1991. After attending Montclair State University, she continued her education online, obtaining certifications in social media management. We have many He shot and killed a local newspaper editor who opposed him, but was found not guilty by reason of insanity. ", Timothy Wiltsey, seen here in a school photo, was reported missing by his mother, Michelle Lodzinski, who was onlycharged in his death decades later. All rights reserved (About Us). 18-Year-Old Man Accused of Killing Neighbor to Become Famous on Tik Tok Allegedly Stolen SUV Falls Over 20 Feet Off New Jersey Embankment People Who Showed Up When No One Came to Birthday Parties . Lockey Mitten, 65, was found stabbed to deathin her Williamstown mobile home on July 28, 2007. For example, the Uniform Crime Reports are released every year by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which are often filled with interesting statistics regarding the sorts of crimes committedwith their respective crime rates in every state. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Police suspected Hall's older and wealthier wife, Frances Stevens Hall, but she wasn't indicted until a local hog farmer called the Pig Woman came forward with claims that she witnessed the soon-to-be-widow and her brother confronting Hall and Mills that day. She was acquitted, and to escape the notoriety, she and her husband moved to Long Island, where they shared a home with another couple. He was 5-feet, 5-inches to . All told, Kee raped and murdered by strangulation three girls over the course of eight years: Paola Illera, 13; Johalis Castro, 19; and Rasheeda Washington, 18. The 69-year-old, who is also known as Assata Shakur, remains on FBI's most wanted terrorist list with a $2 million reward for her capture and return. But he is also believed to have killed at least four other teenaged girls in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Similar to the rest of the country, Mercer County murders crime scene photos are the most common example of evidence shown to the jurors during a homicide trial. Her computer search history also turned up "how to commit murder." The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. Kitty Genovese - HISTORY